Australians are happy with high-tech schools...but some concerns remain
The new school year will see increased amounts of digital technology in classrooms. While the Australian public is largely supportive, specific problems are raised in a new national survey by Monash University.
The use of digital technology in schools has made negative headlines over the past 12 months – including high-profile cases of cyberbullying, proposed phone bans and parental pushback against laptop schemes.
However, Australian adults are largely positive about the overall benefits of technology in schools, with sizable support for the future rollout of online exams, blended learning classes and even facial recognition systems in classrooms within the next 10 years.
But a number of issues continue to concern parents and the wider public. Nearly 40% of adults believe that ‘big tech’ companies such as Google and Microsoft cannot be trusted to play a leading role in supporting schools’ technology use.
Similarly, there is strong public support for mobile phone restrictions – with nearly 80% supporting the idea of classroom bans, and just under one-third support a total schoolwide ban.
Published on Wednesday 23 January 2019, the report titled: ‘Digital Lessons? Public opinions on the use of digital technologies in Australian schools’ is one of the first accounts of national public opinion towards the digitisation of classrooms.
The key findings of the report include:
- 66% of adults agree that digital technologies make a positive contribution to Australian schools
- 37% of adults believe ‘Big Tech’ companies cannot be trusted to play a role in school technology
- 79% of adults support schools banning the use of mobile phones while students are in class
- 44% of adults are happy to see online exams; 34% want blended learning opportunities
- 46% of adults would like facial recognition technology (computerised video tracking in schools to monitor attendance and ensure safety) incorporated into classrooms over the next 10 years
- Just 21% of adults believe that parents should pay for their child’s ‘BYOD’ laptop or digital tablet if schools do not give them a choice of device
The most strongly supported idea throughout the whole survey was the importance of schools to teach students information technology skills that are relevant for future jobs (86.3%).
“For many years, schools were considered to be an important place for young people to gain experience of using computer and internet technology. However, recently there has been growing criticism that many schools are falling well behind what most of today’s students are doing with technology outside of the classroom,” Professor Selwyn said.
Professor Selwyn said he was most surprised to find a high level of support for classroom phone bans from adults who otherwise endorsed the need for increased use of digital technology in schools.
Mobile phones have this year been banned from primary school classrooms across NSW under a government plan to reduce online bullying and unnecessary distraction. Some Victorian secondary schools have also issued schoolyard phone bans.
“But despite the strong sentiment for a classroom phone ban, a large majority of adults in the survey (68%) said it was ok for students to bring a mobile phone to school – mainly for safety and security purposes,” Professor Selwyn said.
Facial recognition was the ‘future tech’ that most adults wanted to see in tomorrow’s classrooms, while the potential introduction of cognition-enhancing drugs – some of which have already been approved for use in the USA – received strong criticism, as did virtual schools.
“Despite overwhelming support for the idea of online exams (44.1%), respondents were relatively disapproving of other technologies that are already beginning to become established in school systems across the world,” Professor Selwyn said.
“We’ve got hundreds of full-time virtual secondary schools in the US, with automated essay grading used for more than three million SAT national tests in the US each year.
“These are trends that are highly likely to become established in Australia throughout the 2020s, yet gain some of the lowest levels of approval in the survey.
“In contrast, we find the much more problematic technology of facial recognition to be getting higher levels of approval.”
In light of the report, Professor Selwyn has called on national policymakers and schools to demonstrate leadership in the area of digital technology education and better engage parents in learning methodologies.
He also says IT companies need to be aware of the “public unease” towards ‘Big Tech’ companies and their key role in determining what goes on in classrooms.
“Although the majority of the Australian public see technology as a legitimate area for government support, EdTech is not a current priority issue at any level of government,” Professor Selwyn said.
“Our survey suggests that this is an area of education where state governments might easily take a lead and play more prominent roles in supporting schools to make the best use of digital technology.”
A full copy of the report can be found at: monash.edu/edfutures