Developing academic communication
About this example
LAW5081 is the first unit in the Master of Laws, with students having substantive knowledge of law in jurisdictions other than Australia. This means that learners are often highly successful in their previous practice, but have limited knowledge of the Australia legal system.
Marnie Brown, lecturer in the Faculty of Law, discusses how she has developed teaching strategies to remove the substantive hidden curriculum through explicitly modeling what legal and academic communication looks like in an Australian context.
Faculty of Law
-
Law has a hidden curriculum and it is enormous. There's a set of expectations we almost never state out loud; how much authority is enough, how close you can paraphrase before it's a problem, what critical analysis actually looks like on a page, as opposed to in a learning outcome? If you grew up in the Australian system, you absorbed most of that by osmosis. If you didn't, nobody hands you the list and you're left guessing and therefore, being marked on your guess. Guessing isn't rigour, it just advantages whoever happens to arrive already knowing.
Further, I work with accomplished professionals who are practising lawyers in their own jurisdictions. This hidden curriculum means they suddenly can't express what they know at the level they know it. That's a genuinely destabilising experience. So, the problem I set out to solve was that we were assessing students on knowledge we'd never explicitly taught in an environment where the students least likely to have that knowledge and were also the least likely to ask.
-
My central principle was to make the invisible visible and never lower the bar. Inclusive teaching is not lowering standards. I hold a high bar and what I do is remove the guessing about where the bar is.
To achieve this, I have made a few small, but significant changes, in how I deliver my units:In-class changes
Firstly, in classes I teach the reasoning explicitly in real time. My seminars are workshops and not lectures. I'll do the legal thinking live and out loud in front of them, including the false starts, and that they do it themselves straight away and get feedback immediately. Watching someone perform the method is very different from being told about it, and language support is embedded into this process and not bolted on.
I also use quick in-class checks and interactive polls to find where learners are actually struggling. This matters as it means learners do not need to ask for help, the support is designed into the workshop. The quiet student is counted. I can then adapt on the spot rather than teaching to an average student who doesn't exist.
The change I'm probably most proud of is the workshop assistance. Students benefit from smaller classes and where the university couldn't accommodate smaller classes, a second educator in the room was the next best thing. It means someone can get to a student mid activity quietly, without them having to raise a hand in front of many people.
Assessment resources
I take the guess work out of developing assessments by providing assessment roadmaps, annotated exemplars, referencing guidance, and practical checklists. These make the processes and expected outcomes of the assessment clear, showing what a student needs to do, and why it works. These have all been developed based on what I have seen as I have been marking.
-
Students asking questions
The outcome I care about most is that students keep asking questions. That sounds small, but with this cohort that is significant. A student who is still asking Week 10 is a student who is still learning.
Workshop assistant model
The workshop assistants have also been an outcome in their own right, and the model was taken up more widely across the faculty. The assistants and colleagues who have taught alongside me have been very positive about the interactive approach. Several have said that teaching in the unit made them reconsider aspects of their own teaching and delivery.
Positive student evaluations
What students tell me in my evaluations is that the teaching style and learning materials are well organised and accessible, making complex legal concepts easier to understand. They describe the combination of clear materials and practical application as engaging, and say it supports a deeper understanding of the subject matter, and that combination is doing specific work for this cohort.
PhD auditing
One of the outcomes that generally surprised me is that my current Australian legal process and research class is being audited by international PhD students in law. They're not enrolled, nor do they get any credit, they're coming because they want a stronger grasp of the Australian legal process and the academic legal writing conventions expected here. Their feedback has been extremely positive, and a growing number of international doctoral candidates have asked whether they can actually attend.
Try it out
This example requires a medium amount of effort to implement.
Recommended resources and training:
- If you have a large teaching team, consider strategies that will help ensure consistency in approach across the teaching team.
-
Identify your hidden curriculum
The single highest value thing anyone can do is write down the thing you assume everyone knows. Sit with your own assessment task and ask what a student would need to already understand for this to make sense.
That list is your hidden curriculum. Teach it. It usually takes an hour to write and it changes outcomes for the students furthest from the norm.
Develop exemplars with annotations
Create exemplars for your students that include annotations. A model answer on its own tells the student what to imitate. An annotated one tells them what's actually happening and why it works, which is what they can transfer to the next task.
Embed support
Work student support into your classes. This approach costs the student nothing, and you are able to reach everyone.
The moment support comes and opt in service that a student has to identify themselves to access. You lose exactly the students who need it because asking costs them something.
Use a Workshop assistant model
Being able to reach a student quietly mid task changes what they're willing to admit they don't understand. -
Start from the assumption that your students are capable
With international and EAL cohorts, the deficit framing is close to the surface and students can feel it instantly. Mine are qualified lawyers. They're not less capable. They are operating in an unfamiliar system, in an additional language. And those are completely different things. How you frame it changes what students will risk in your classroom.
Be consistently present
Predictable communication and an encouraging tone. Normalising uncertainty as a normal part of learning a learning discipline rather than evidence. You shouldn't be here. I'm also explicit with students that legal reasoning and legal writing are learnable professional skills and not talent. That one sentence does an enormous amount of work with a cohort that arrives capable but unconfident.
Take smalls steps
This is about completely redesigning your unit. It's an annotated exemplar. It's writing down an expectation you'd been carrying in your head. It's five minutes at the start of a seminar naming what students are finding hard so they know it isn't just them. Small things done consistently.
Normalise uncertainty
Let students know it is okay to have questions, or to feel unsure. I'm explicit with students that legal reasoning and legal writing are learnable professional skills and not talent. That one sentence does an enormous amount of work with a cohort that arrives capable but unconfident.
Supporting resources
Here are some additional resources that you can browse to help you implement this assessment.